ScarJo vs. LiLo: The Battle for the Next Marilyn

Scarlett Johansson poses as Marilyn Monroe for Dolce & Gabbana. But who does the best job playing the screen siren?

By Breanne L. Heldman Jan 21, 2009 3:40 PMTags
E! Placeholder Image

With the scarlet lips and curly blond 'do, there's no question Dolce & Gabbana wanted the face of its new makeup line to channel Marilyn Monroe.

So who better to hire than Scarlett Johansson? There's no question she exudes Old Hollywood glamour.

But what about Lindsay Lohan, who re-created the icon's "Last Sitting" for New York Magazine last year?

Who do you think makes the better Marilyn (and, yes, lifestyle antics count)?

Poll

The Cover Girl Conundrum

Which current starlet is the best Marilyn Monroe poser?
It's obviously Scarlett—no question
71.3%
Lindsay is willing to take it all off! 'Nuf said
19.2%
I have no jones for ScarJo and I'm low on LiLo, so I've entered my suggestion below
9.4%