4/6
Todd Wawrychuk/ABC via Getty Images
Technically speaking, this moment occurred on the After the Final Rose episode of Dorfman's season in 2014, though the format is almost identical to the Men Tell All specials. A distraught Nick Viall shocked many when he shared details of their intimacy on live TV, which Dorfman considered "below the belt."
The Atlanta-based attorney defended her decision to send Viall, who went on to become the Bachelor three years later, home before the final rose ceremony. Since then, Andi and Nick have put their differences aside and remain friends.